Jurisdiction: UK-wide. England and Wales use DBS, Scotland uses Disclosure Scotland, and Northern Ireland uses AccessNI. Right to Work rules are the same in all four nations.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Employment law and screening regulations vary by jurisdiction. Consult a qualified legal professional before making compliance decisions.
The DBS check is the UK's best-known criminal record check, yet it covers only England and Wales. Employers hiring in Glasgow, Aberdeen, Belfast, or Derry work with two other bodies, each with its own check levels, fees, and rules for roles involving children and vulnerable adults.
For a multi-site employer, that can look like three separate processes. In practice, the three systems map onto each other closely enough to run as one vetting standard. Here is how Disclosure Scotland and AccessNI differ from DBS, and how to keep hiring consistent across all four nations.
Criminal justice is devolved, so each jurisdiction keeps its own records framework and disclosure law. Disclosure Scotland runs checks for Scotland, AccessNI runs them for Northern Ireland, and the Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) covers England and Wales.
The split matters most for higher-level checks. Scotland reformed its system under the Disclosure (Scotland) Act 2020, with new check levels from 1 April 2025. Northern Ireland uses the same level names as DBS, but checks go through AccessNI's own registered bodies.
Use the body for the nation where the role is based. Scotland's guidance confirms that people based elsewhere in the UK go to DBS or AccessNI, even when their work involves customers in Scotland. The main exception covers regulated roles carried out in Scotland, covered below.
Disclosure Scotland offers four products. Level 1 replaced the basic disclosure, and Level 2 replaced most standard and enhanced disclosures. The 2020 Act aims to protect the public while balancing people's need to move on from past offending.
Anyone can apply for a Level 1 disclosure, which shows unspent convictions. As the Scottish equivalent of a basic DBS check, Level 1 is the usual choice for general employment.
Level 2 is reserved for specific roles, such as solicitors and prison workers. The certificate shows unspent convictions, certain spent convictions, and other information such as notification requirements. The organisation must start the application, and a barred list version exists for specific activities.
The Protecting Vulnerable Groups (PVG) scheme is where Scotland differs most from England and Wales:
Membership is a legal requirement for anyone doing a regulated role with children or protected adults
Since 1 April 2026, membership lasts five years rather than for life
Disclosure Scotland keeps checking members' suitability until they leave the scheme
Checks for roles with children include criminal records from certain EU countries of nationality, including Poland, Romania, and Ireland
Continuous monitoring is the headline difference. A DBS certificate reflects the date it was issued unless the holder joins the DBS Update Service, while PVG membership is kept under review automatically.
AccessNI offers basic, standard, and enhanced checks, so the levels will feel familiar to anyone used to DBS. Anyone aged 16 or over can apply for a basic check, and employers can ask all job applicants for one.
Standard and enhanced checks must be countersigned by an AccessNI registered body. Standard checks apply only to roles exempt from the Rehabilitation of Offenders (Northern Ireland) Order 1978. Enhanced checks add relevant police information and, for regulated activity, information held by DBS, which makes barring decisions for Northern Ireland.
AccessNI publishes service targets for each level. The targets are 99% of standard checks within seven days, and 95% of enhanced checks within 21 days. Applications go to the police where the person has convictions or police information, or has lived in Ireland in the last five years, which can add time.
Set side by side, the three systems line up as follows.
| Factor | DBS (England and Wales) | Disclosure Scotland | AccessNI (Northern Ireland) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Entry-level check | Basic, £20 | Level 1, £25 | Basic, £16 |
| Higher-level checks | Standard £20, enhanced £41 | Level 2 and Level 2 with barred list, £25 | Standard £16, enhanced £32 |
| Roles with children or vulnerable adults | Enhanced check with barred lists | PVG scheme membership, £59 to join | Enhanced check, including DBS barring information |
| Who can apply for the entry-level check | The individual, or an employer through a responsible organisation | Anyone | Anyone aged 16 or over |
Fees are the statutory charges each body publishes. Registered bodies and umbrella organisations may add their own administration fees.
Three bodies do not need three policies. One vetting standard, mapped to each nation's equivalent check, keeps decisions fair and audit-ready.
Define each role's package once, such as "entry-level criminal record check plus Right to Work and identity". Then map it to the right product in each nation. A warehouse supervisor in Leeds, Livingston, and Lisburn gets the equivalent check, issued by the right body.
Right to Work works the same way across the UK. Identity verification, employment history, and references can follow one process everywhere. Only the criminal record channel changes by nation, so central teams can standardise everything else.
Each body works through its own network of organisations. In England and Wales, registered bodies and responsible organisations submit DBS applications. Organisations in Scotland register with Disclosure Scotland to start Level 2 and PVG applications. In Northern Ireland, registered bodies handle standard and enhanced checks, and responsible bodies or umbrella bodies can process basic checks. Setting up all three channels before a hiring push avoids delays on the first application in a new nation.
Record which body ran each check, the level, the date, and the outcome. A single record per candidate makes it easy to show regulators and auditors that every nation followed the same standard. TraqCheck's approach to global workforce verification applies the same principle across borders.
Most multi-site employers need a few extra rules on top of their standard process. Three situations come up regularly.
Scottish Government guidance on mygov.scot is clear on this point. Anyone doing a regulated role in Scotland must be a PVG member, even if DBS or AccessNI already checked them for the same role. The rule applies when work in Scotland is a normal part of the role, including for organisations based elsewhere in the UK.
When someone moves to a site in another nation, review whether the new role needs a different level of check. For regulated roles moving into Scotland, PVG membership applies. Agreeing in advance who triggers that review, usually the receiving site's HR lead, keeps the move on schedule.
None of the three UK bodies covers time spent living abroad, apart from the PVG scheme's checks against certain EU nationalities. Where the role justifies it, an overseas criminal record search covers those years. With TraqCheck, those searches run through an AI background verification agent that reaches 190+ countries, alongside identity, employment, and education verification. For a refresher on levels in England and Wales, see our guide to DBS checks explained.
Disclosure Scotland and AccessNI follow the same logic as DBS: an entry-level check for most roles, higher levels for specific positions, and stronger protections for work with children and vulnerable adults. The differences sit in names, fees, and Scotland's PVG scheme. Map one role-based standard onto all three, and multi-site hiring stays consistent. When you are ready to bring every check into one workflow, launch screening with TRACE.
A Disclosure Scotland check is a criminal record check for roles in Scotland. The levels are Level 1, Level 2, Level 2 with barred list check, and PVG scheme membership for regulated roles.
An AccessNI check is a criminal record check for Northern Ireland. AccessNI offers basic, standard, and enhanced checks, and standard and enhanced checks go through a registered body.
Generally, use Disclosure Scotland for roles based in Scotland. Anyone doing a regulated role in Scotland must be a PVG member, even if they already hold a DBS check for the same role.
Choose one workflow that routes each check to the right body, applies one role-based standard, and records results centrally. TRACE adds identity, employment, education, and international checks with human review of every result.
Most map one role-based package onto each nation's equivalent check and keep Right to Work, identity, and employment checks the same everywhere. A single record per candidate shows which body ran each check.
AccessNI charges £16 for basic and standard checks and £32 for enhanced checks. Registered bodies may add an administration fee, and volunteers can get standard or enhanced checks free in some cases.


