Jurisdiction: UK. The Right to Work scheme operates in all four nations, and the data protection points refer to UK GDPR.
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Employment law and screening regulations vary by jurisdiction. Consult a qualified legal professional before making compliance decisions.
A contractor placed by an agency and paid through an umbrella company can have three businesses between them and the client site. Each business has a part in the hire, and the Right to Work check belongs to one of them in particular. Knowing which one, and what the others still need to confirm, keeps the whole chain clear.
The question is sharper since 1 October 2026, when the Right to Work scheme widened, and fresh Home Office guidance took effect. GOV.UK guidance for agencies already expected them to confirm that umbrella companies run and record these checks. Below, those threads come together, along with the wider screening that sits around the Right to Work check.
An umbrella company employs a contractor and pays them for assignments that an agency arranges with an end client. GOV.UK guidance for employment businesses states the umbrella company will usually be the worker's employer, responsible for paying wages and operating Pay As You Earn (PAYE).
The end client, where the contractor carries out the work
The employment business, often called the agency, which finds the work and agrees the assignment rate
The umbrella company, which employs the contractor and runs payroll
The contractor, who is an employee of the umbrella company
Many contractors whose engagements fall inside the off-payroll working rules, often called IR35, work through umbrella companies rather than their own limited company. New PAYE rules for labour supply chains that include umbrella companies also took effect on 6 April 2026. Government guidance notes plans to bring umbrella companies within the legal definition of an employment business as well.
The umbrella company carries out the check, because it holds the direct contract of employment. Home Office guidance states the principle plainly. Where an employer has a direct contract with a worker, that employer remains responsible for the prescribed check.
Agencies keep an active role. GOV.UK guidance for employers lists preventing illegal working among their duties, including checking that umbrella companies are carrying out and recording Right to Work checks on temporary workers. In practice, that means asking to see evidence, not simply relying on a contract clause.
A statutory excuse belongs to the employer that earned it. If a contractor moves to a different umbrella company, even mid-assignment, the new umbrella company becomes the employer and runs its own check before employment with it begins. Agencies that track umbrella changes can prompt that check early, so the assignment continues without a pause.
In a standard supply arrangement, where contractors work within the client's own operations, the end client is not expected to repeat the check. The position changes where the client is itself contracted to deliver services onward to a third party through a chain of contracts. In that case, the extended liability provisions may apply to the client.
Responsibilities usually split across the chain like this:
| Party | Typical relationship to the contractor | Right to Work role | Evidence worth keeping |
|---|---|---|---|
| Umbrella company | Employer under a contract of employment | Carries out the prescribed check before employment starts | Check record, kept for the employment plus two years |
| Agency | Arranges the assignment, no employment contract | Confirms the umbrella company runs and records checks | Due diligence notes and evidence requests |
| End client, standard supply | Receives the contractor's services for its own operations | No routine duplicate check expected | Supplier terms allocating responsibility |
| End client, onward service chain | Delivers services to a third party through the chain | May be subject to extended liability | Written statement and contract terms the guide prescribes |
The table reflects common arrangements. The guide stresses that the contractual facts decide each case, so unusual structures deserve their own review.
The expanded scheme and the new guide adjusted several points that touch umbrella arrangements. Four matter most:
People engaged on a worker's contract or as individual sub-contractors fall within the scheme, alongside employees, closing gaps in some contractor models.
Extended liability can reach a business further up a chain where it delivers services to a third party through subcontracted labour.
Digital Right to Work checks have to run through a provider listed by the Office for Digital Identities and Attributes.
Apart from a check through a registered provider, an employer cannot rely on a check run independently by another party, such as an agency.
The fourth point is worth pausing on. An umbrella company cannot treat an agency's own check as its statutory excuse. Each employer runs, or commissions through a registered provider, its own prescribed check. The guide does allow a registered provider to be engaged indirectly, through a screening or onboarding platform, provided the output names the registered provider that carried out the check.
The guide confirms the measures are not retrospective. The relevant date is when the contractual arrangement was entered into, so an assignment agreed before 1 October 2026 is not brought into scope simply because it continues. Renewals and variations may need a fresh look. Our guide to Right to Work checks for contractors and temps covers the wider scheme change.
Beyond Right to Work, screening for umbrella contractors follows the same rules as for any hire. The difference is that responsibility for each check is shared out by contract rather than held by one employer.
An employer, or a third party acting on an employer's behalf, can request a DBS check where the role justifies it. For umbrella contractors, the agency or end client often arranges the check because it understands the role. The level still follows the role, and the contractor consents in the usual way.
Agencies often verify work history and references before submitting a contractor, because the end client relies on that profile when accepting them. Agencies also carry their own duties under the Conduct of Employment Agencies and Employment Businesses Regulations 2003.
Each business that handles a contractor's screening data needs a lawful basis and a clear purpose under UK GDPR. Sharing only what each party needs, and agreeing roles in writing, keeps data flows tidy. Our guide to UK GDPR and background checks explains the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) expectations in detail.
GOV.UK sets out practical checks for agencies working with umbrella companies. The most useful for screening and compliance teams include:
Confirming the umbrella company's details match Companies House records
Checking it is VAT-registered and charging VAT correctly
Obtaining payslips directly from workers to confirm it acts as the employer and runs PAYE
Finding out whether it outsources employer responsibilities, and checking that third party too
Keeping a record of the due diligence carried out
Adding a request for Right to Work evidence to that list connects tax diligence with immigration compliance. A simple sample check works well, such as asking for the check records of five contractors chosen at random each quarter. Recruitment agencies that run supplier reviews quarterly often fold both into one routine.
Umbrella arrangements work well when every party knows its part. The umbrella company checks Right to Work as an employer, the agency confirms that check happens and is recorded, and the end client sets clear supplier terms. Written allocation of DBS, reference, and data responsibilities completes the picture for compliance and risk teams.
TRACE supports that shared model as a candidate screening platform, running identity, employment, and international checks with a full audit trail and human review of every result. Agencies and umbrella partners can work from one shared screening workflow, and the quickest way to build it is to start verifying with a pilot group.
The umbrella company, as the contractor's employer with the direct contract, carries out the prescribed check. The agency should confirm the umbrella company runs and records these checks.
Not in a standard supply arrangement for the client's own operations. Extended liability may apply where the client delivers services onward to a third party through a chain of contracts.
Not on its own. The Home Office guide states an employer cannot establish a statutory excuse through a check run independently by a third party. The exception is a check carried out by a registered digital verification provider.
No. IR35 decides how tax applies to an engagement, not whether a Right to Work check is needed. The employer with the direct contract runs the check either way.
Any employer, or a third party acting on an employer's behalf, can request a DBS check where the role is eligible. The agency or end client often arranges it, and the contract should say which.
Ask for confirmation that each contractor's Right to Work check was completed before employment started and is stored. Pair that with the GOV.UK due diligence checks, such as Companies House details and worker payslips.


